I know this is like refuting the bible to some people
and probably as alien to others as my distaste for the Beatles
but I only read JD Salinger in school because we had to
and although I enjoyed the story well enough
(and you know which one it was)
I never really got what the uproar was about
or why it was controversial
or what it had to do with me
It didn't change my life
or inspire me to become a bitter old recluse
or fight the system
or reject authority
or whatever it was meant to do
and I never re-read the story
or picked up anything else he had written(did he actually write much?)
and since he was an old man
whose name never entered my head more than once or twice
since those school days
I can’t carry on about his death
or try to intellectualize his impact on me
or write a morose Facebook status
like all those people
half at least of which I bet rarely even pick up a book
let alone read enough to care
about an old, dead author
whose only influence on their life was forced
and who probably only read the Coles Notes version
(which he didn’t write by the way)
and the great bandwagon of celebrity death
rolls on and on
and if you don’t jump on guess what,
it doesn’t run you over
(yes, yes I know SOME people really DO care about this. But NO WAY do ALL the people who are babbling about it care as much as they want to seem to. I believe they truly do just see this as a way to have his witty quotes as their Facebook status, for sure).
9 dirty hippies blowing your mind:
what?? come on now. first of all, the reason Catcher In The Rye is considered so important is because of -when- it was released. you have to remember that it was, at the time, a rather frank look at the malaise of young people in a time when America was reveling in it's post-war boom. society in general would have had a hard time thinking that any young person would feel any sort of malaise or discontent. the fact that Salinger manages to so effectively capture the era from a young man's point of view, while effectively exposing the cracks in the veneer of the notion of the perfect American Family ... well, it was a revelation at the time. Salinger wrote very little -- or rather, he publsihed very little, but his 'Nine Stories' is also excellent and captures much of the same sort of frustration and suburban discontent as Richard Yates would a decade later. Salinger, in the end, along with Frank O'Hara and Jack Kerouac and a few others, was one of the most important writers of the 50's. 'Catcher In The Rye' means a lot to a lot of people, including myself.
maybe I'm a sociopath. This kind of thing doesn't really ever mean all that much to me. Don't get me wrong, I appreciate the talent and the validity of the writing at a given time etc....
I just can't with any honesty say that it (or he, or any other book I've actually loved and read tons of times) has affected my life beyond giving me extreme reading enjoyment and a moment of escape.
Seriously, just being honest. I'm definitely smart enough that I could write a fawning and believably accurate and indeed perhaps poignantly affecting tribute to the man and his work. But it wouldn't be from the heart; it would just be bandwaggoning (??) or grandstanding or whatever.
I think I did tell a lie though... I think I did read Franny and Zooey... but I can't remember the details I'm afraid.
Deep as an ocean, deep as a puddle I am.
really? that's a shame. i definitely have a few books that have meant and continue to mean the world to me. they inform who i am, how i see life, they fuel my imagination and continually restore my faith in art and the possibilities for art to elevate us. it makes me kinda sad that you have never experienced that from reading a great work of fiction. art -- especially music and film -- is such an essential part of my life i cannot imagine it NOT having the ability to move me and change me and help me evolve. you're dead inside, lady!
I KNOW!
oh and music is a different matter altogether for me... I definitely feel a lot in that regard.
gimme yr address. you clearly need some Nine Stories action.
fuck facebook.
Catcher was a good book, but your reaction to his passing and the lit itself, I understand...I can hear your reaction like when I was out to dinner this evening and overheard some douchebag say "Fight Club changed my life man...bichin' movie."
I nearly choked on my Spider Roll
Tony... really? You planning to send me some reading material?
Post a Comment